1. Home
  2. Extended Auto Warranty

Find the Best Extended Auto Warranty Companies in Cincinnati, OH

Unexpected car repairs, especially ones that affect the engine or transmission, can be expensive. Extended auto warranties, which cover problems not included in the original manufacturer warranty and extend the life of your coverage, can protect your vehicle as it ages. We researched the best extended auto warranties in Cincinnati to help you choose the right protection for your car.

Take a Quiz

Get matched with an Accredited Partner

Compare Top Extended Auto Warranties

#1 OUR FAVORITE
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Available in Cincinnati
  • Multiple levels of coverage
  • Accepted by dealers & ASE mechanics
  • 24-hour roadside assistance

Coverage when you need it!

Learn More Read More
#2
Overall satisfaction rating
  • No-haggle guarantee
  • Roadside plans for $59.95
  • Available in Cincinnati
  • Mobile app

Select 3 plan options with deductibles as low as $100. Covers vehicles for up to 5 years or 125,000 miles.

Learn More Read More
#3
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Available in Cincinnati
  • Powertrain & specialty plans
  • Coverage for recreational vehicles
  • Plans for every vehicle & budget

Flexible payment plans, coverage on pricey items like transmissions and 24-hour roadside assistance are just a few of the features offered in CarShield’s customizable plans.

Learn More Read More
#4
Accredited Partner
Infinite Auto
Overall satisfaction rating
  • A+ BBB Rating
  • 24/7 roadside assistance
  • Guarantees 100% payment in event of any breakdown
  • Available in Cincinnati

A+ Rated with the BBB. Infinite Auto Protection provides coverage for your vehicle in the event of any breakdown and guarantees 100% payment, less any deductibles, of all covered repairs.

Learn More Read More
#5
Accredited Partner
Protect My Car
Overall satisfaction rating
  • 3 plans available
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • Available in Cincinnati
  • Rental car benefits

Protect My Car allows a long 60-month repayment plan. Although their Ambassador plan only offers partial coverage, Protect My Car’s other plans satisfy a wide array of needs.

Learn More
#6
American Auto Shield
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Available in Cincinnati
  • Serving customers for over a decade
  • Resolves claims quickly
  • Your choice of mechanic
Location
Serves residents in
Cincinnati, OH
(800) 531-1925
AA Auto Protection
  • Wear & tear coverage options
  • Resolves claims quickly
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
  • Available in Cincinnati
Location
Serves residents in
Cincinnati, OH
(888) 222-4445
Delta Auto Protect
Overall satisfaction rating
  • ASE-licensed technicians on staff
  • Available in Cincinnati
  • Customizable plans
  • Price match promise
Location
Serves residents in
Cincinnati, OH
(866) 598-5429

How to choose an extended auto warranty in Cincinnati

Cincinnati skyline

Car maintenance is a common expense for drivers in the Cincinnati area. Winter temperatures often dip below freezing, creating potholes and crumbling roads that can cause expensive damage to vehicles. An estimated 23 percent of Ohio’s roads are in poor condition, and an additional 12 percent are rated as mediocre.

Car insurance or the original manufacturer warranty do not usually cover damage caused by poor road conditions, so these costly repairs are typically paid out-of-pocket. The Bureau of Labor Statistics says the average driver spends $660 per year on car maintenance and repairs. Cincinnati residents should look to extended auto warranties to protect them from unexpected costs.

You can purchase extended auto warranties in addition to the original manufacturer or dealer warranty. Extended auto warranties can close the gaps in the original manufacturer warranty and provide coverage that lasts long after the original warranty expires. Unlike car insurance, which covers costs from accidents and theft, extended auto warranties focus on repairing your car if it breaks down.

There’s a deductible ranging from $50 to $200, and you may be required to use an in-network garage for the repairs. Avoid plans that have a higher deductible or require you to pay up-front for costs and be reimbursed later.

The types of repairs covered by your warranty vary greatly from plan to plan. Some auto warranties in Cincinnati only cover basic repairs to certain components, while others offer bumper-to-bumper coverage and routine maintenance.

Adding extra coverage will increase the warranty cost, but that isn’t the only thing that affects the price of an extended auto warranty in Cincinnati. Other factors include:

  • Age and mileage: If you’re purchasing a used car, the cost of your warranty is based on the age and mileage of the vehicle. Some providers only offer warranties on vehicles below a certain mileage, while others cater to cars with more miles on them.
  • Parts covered: There are many levels of coverage available, allowing customers in Cincinnati to choose which parts of the vehicle are covered by their warranty. The most basic, low-cost plans won’t cover required maintenance or standard repairs such as brake replacement.
  • Warranty term: Your extended warranty will last until your car reaches a designated age or mileage, whichever comes first. The longer the term, the more expensive the plan will be. Practice caution with extended warranty companies that advertise unusually high terms and make sure your warranty will last long enough to be useful.

Be sure to read the fine print when selecting your extended auto warranty. Ideally, your plan will not have a waiting period more than 30 days or a long list of exclusions. You should also review the company’s repair network and claims process before making your choice.

Extended Auto Warranty Reviews

Endurance

Endurance offers four levels of extended auto warranties, providing options for every price point or coverage need. The company can help you find the plan that’s right for you, and all warranties are administered in-house so you never have to go through a middleman. Customers in Cincinnati say the company has top-notch customer service.

Endurance Learn More

CARCHEX

CARCHEX’s extended auto warranty comparison will help you find the best price on the Cincinnati market. A knowledgeable service agent will match you with a plan that suits your vehicle, budget and maintenance needs. Customers in Cincinnati report great results with their service plans and appreciate CARCHEX’s helpfulness throughout the process.

CARCHEX Learn More

CarShield

CarShield covers both new and used cars, even those with high mileage. They advertise having a plan for every vehicle and budget, and they have a responsive customer service team and favorable reviews in Cincinnati. Ask about their specialty coverage if you have specific needs not covered by other extended warranties.

CarShield Learn More

Infinite Auto

Infinite Auto Protection offers three extended auto warranty plans. Each comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee and 24/7 roadside assistance. Customers like being able to take their vehicles to any dealership or certified repair shop and say Infinite Auto Protection has an efficient claims process and low deductible.

Infinite Auto Learn More