1. Home
  2. Home Warranty

Find the Best Home Warranty in Cincinnati, OH

Costly repairs of home systems and appliances come as an unpleasant surprise to Cincinnati residents. You can protect yourself financially with a home warranty, which will provide coverage after the manufacturer’s guarantee expires. We researched the best home warranty in Cincinnati to help keep your home running smoothly.

Take a Quiz

Get matched with an Accredited Partner

Compare Top Home Warranties, Service Plans

Accredited Partner
American Home Shield
Overall satisfaction rating
  • 4 coverage plans
  • Starting at $75 deductible
  • Coverage regardless of age or make
  • Available in Cincinnati

Be sure with The Shield.

Learn More (888) 395-0951 Read More
Accredited Partner
Choice Home Warranty
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Request service online
  • Customizable plans
  • Available in Cincinnati
  • Get a free quote online

Choice Home Warranty offers comprehensive protection plans that protect against the high cost of repair or replacement of properly maintained major systems and appliances.

Learn More (732) 765-6416 Read More
Accredited Partner
Liberty Home Guard
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Month-to-month, annual or multiyear policies
  • Repair or replace your broken items
  • Plans start at less than $1 per day
  • 24/7 customer claims service

Liberty Home Guard gives you the choice to repair or replace your broken items, and provides plans for less than $1 per day, with discounts for multi-year policies.

Learn More (646) 453-6807 Read More
Accredited Partner
Total Home Protection
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Affordable coverage
  • Work with local technicians
  • Available in Cincinnati
  • Optional coverage add-ons

Offers 2 coverage plans that both cover select systems and appliances. Premium costs vary by location and home with standard deductibles of $60.

Learn More (704) 253-8240 Read More
Accredited Partner
America's 1st Choice Home Club
Overall satisfaction rating
  • 2 coverage plan options
  • Fixed rate locked in with no year-to-year increases
  • No limit on service requests
  • Flexibility to choose your own service technician

With four plans to choose from based on your needs, and the ability to pay by the month, or to get a discount pay yearly, America's First Choice is a great pick for any homeowner.

Learn More (678) 236-0645 Read More
Accredited Partner
Select Home Warranty
Overall satisfaction rating
  • Get your free quote online
  • 3 levels of coverage
  • Available in Cincinnati
  • Payment plans that fit your budget

Select Home Warranty provides home warranty service plans that cover home repairs. They have a wide range of options to choose from and offer customizable plans.

Learn More (317) 754-6642 Read More

Why do I need a home warranty in Cincinnati?

Cincinnati skyline

Purchasing a home warranty is a cost-effective decision for many homeowners in Cincinnati. Whether you’re putting your house on the market, managing a rental property or looking to maintain your home as it ages, these plans cut costs on repairs to major components and appliances.

Temperatures in Cincinnati often fall below freezing in winter and rise during muggy summers, requiring reliable heating and cooling systems to keep residents comfortable. In neighborhoods with historic houses like Over-the-Rhine or Mt. Adams, repairs to these systems can be particularly expensive.

How much does a home warranty cost in Cincinnati?

A home warranty in Cincinnati usually costs between $600 to $1,200 per year, with policies ranging from as low as $145 to nearly $3,000.

Home warranty policyholders can usually choose to pay monthly or annually for coverage. If something breaks, you contact the warranty company, which will then send a technician from within its network. You pay a small service fee for the technician’s diagnosis, and if the appliance or system is covered, the warranty company will pay for its repair or replacement.

Home warranty coverage in Cincinnati

Depending on the coverage, your policy may fall into the following tiers:

Coverage Level Included
Basic HVAC systems, plumbing systems, electrical systems, major appliances (e.g., dishwasher, built-in microwave, refrigerator, oven range, laundry machines)
Extended Pool, spa, garage door, garage door opener, septic system; other systems may be added at additional cost

As you look for the right home warranty, be certain that systems and appliances that matter to you are covered. Read reviews to find out if customers find the claims process easy or if they experience difficulty getting repairs and replacements done. If you suspect any signs of a scam, check to see if the company is accredited and rated by the Better Business Bureau.

Keep in mind that home warranties are not the same as homeowners insurance. A warranty protects you from breakdowns due to wear and tear, while an insurance policy pays to repair damages caused by fire, weather, theft and other events. Insurance may be required for your home, but warranties are optional and can be purchased at any time.

Home Warranty Reviews

Accredited Partner

American Home Shield

With American Home Shield, you can customize your plan to cover what’s important to you, or you can choose from three standard plans to meet your Cincinnati home maintenance needs. Optional coverage is available for pools and spas, well pumps and septic pumps. Service fees range from $75 to $125, and customers get access to discounts on appliances and air filters. Reviewers report good value for the price.

American Home Shield Learn More (888) 395-0951
Accredited Partner

Choice Home Warranty

Choice Home Warranty offers a basic plan and a total plan, which adds on coverage of an air conditioning system, refrigerator and washer and dryer. Customers can also add optional coverage for a pool/spa, sump pump, septic system and other items. The standard service call fee is $75. Choice Home Warranty gets generally good reviews from customers, with many appreciative of prompt, professional service.

Choice Home Warranty Learn More (732) 765-6416
Accredited Partner

Liberty Home Guard

With appliance and system plans starting at less than $1 per day, Liberty Home Guard offers flexible plans that let you tailor coverage to fit your home needs. Customer support is open 24/7 and Liberty says that empathy and integrity are core company values.

Liberty Home Guard Learn More (646) 453-6807
Accredited Partner

Total Home Protection

Total Home Protection offers two different home warranty plans, with options for add-on coverage of a pool, spa, sump pump and more. Customers get 24/7 access to claims service and the benefit of prescreened, licensed and insured service contractors. There is no limit to the number of claims you can place and no fee to transfer a policy to a new homeowner. Reviewers appreciate how easy it is to submit claims and the follow-up from customer service after repairs.

Total Home Protection Learn More (704) 253-8240
Accredited Partner

America's 1st Choice Home Club

With tiered pricing options, AFC Home Club makes it easy to see what is and is not covered under its three plans. Choose one that fits your home’s needs and buy extra coverage to protect additional appliances and systems. There’s no deductible, only a $60 service fee. Plans include restaurant gift cards and a retail savings program for cash back at 5,000 retailers.

America's 1st Choice Home Club Learn More (678) 236-0645
Accredited Partner

Select Home Warranty

Select Home Warranty has three plans available: appliances, systems or a comprehensive plan that includes both. Customers are covered for an unlimited number of repairs, which are serviced by a network of 10,000 qualified contractors. Policyholders in Cincinnati say Select Home Warranty is affordable and there for you when problems arise.

Select Home Warranty Learn More (317) 754-6642